Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1 Review: Is Kyle’s Loyalty to Mike Going to Cost Him Everything

By Paul Johnson 10/26/2025

When I pressed play on Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1, I braced myself for chaos, and the episode delivered. From the very first scene, I felt like I’d been thrown straight into the eye of the storm. New faces, old grudges, and power plays litter every corner of Kingstown, and if you thought last season left things messy, buckle up: things have gotten even nastier.

Before I get into my take, let me briefly refresh everyone on where we left off in Mayor of Kingstown season 3. Mike McLusky (Jeremy Renner) had avenged his mother’s death by taking Milo Sunter out, but the aftermath was devastating. Ian tried to get Iris out of town, yet her own demons caught up with her, ending her life in a tragic overdose; Mike remains in the dark.

Meanwhile, Merle Callahan survived an assassination attempt, and Kyle, Mike’s younger brother, took the fall for shooting a rogue cop. It’s messy, it’s brutal, and it’s Kingstown!

Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1: New Threats and Power Shifts





Right out of the gate, we meet Frank Moses, the new gangster who doesn’t waste time making his presence known. The opening sequence, thugs on train tracks meeting a grisly end, set the tone. Moses is ruthless, and his arrival promises to stir the pot for everyone: Mike, Bunny, Ian, and even the Aryan gang.

Watching it, I couldn’t help but feel a shiver down my spine; this isn’t just another player joining the game; he’s a force that could topple the whole house. Yes, this isn’t a show that spares its characters, and Kyle’s vulnerability highlights just how dangerous this world is.

Kyle Takes the Fall in Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1?  

Kyle needs his own spotlight here. His storyline immediately grabs my attention in the series from the Yellowstone helmer. He is now serving a 2-year sentence after Mike’s lawyer reduced it from 20 years, but Kingstown Penitentiary is far from safe. Every inmate and guard could pose a threat, and Kyle’s decision to refuse to testify against Robert Sawyer is the moral heart of this episode.

By staying silent, Kyle protects Mike, Ian, and other officers who have bent the law to keep Kingstown somewhat orderly, but he risks his own life, his career, and his future. Watching Kyle navigate Ad Seg, taking bruises from violent inmates, makes you feel the full weight of his choices. His moral conflict, protecting family versus self-preservation, is where the show’s drama hits hardest.

Kyle wants out of Kingstown, but staying silent is the only way to safeguard those he loves.

Nina Hobbs in Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1: New Warden is Not Messing Around

One of my favorite aspects of this episode was Nina Hobbs. She’s a no-nonsense warden who isn’t about to give Mike, or anyone else, special treatment. Watching Mike try to negotiate Kyle’s safety with her was fascinating. She made it clear: rules come first, no exceptions. For me, that refusal made her instantly intriguing.

I can already tell she’s going to shake things up, and I love that the show isn’t giving the McLuskys an easy ride. Nina also confronted Kevin Jackson, hinting she knows about his loyalties and issuing subtle warnings. I’m keeping an eye on him because loyalty in Kingstown isn’t just gray; it’s a full-on minefield.

Kyle’s Dilemma and the Weight of Silence in Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1

Kyle’s refusal to testify against Robert Sawyer hit me harder than I expected. His loyalty to Mike and the other cops forces him into silence, and that moral conflict is where this show truly excels. Watching him grapple with protecting his family while losing his future in Kingstown made me question what I would do in his shoes. He’s the human anchor amidst the gang wars, and I genuinely felt his frustration, fear, and resolve as the episode progressed.

The episode didn’t let up on the gang politics either. Bunny and Raphael Johnson’s old arrangements with the Spanish gang are strained. The Spanish seem to have a shadowy backer, making their moves unpredictable.

The car attack on Bunny at the episode’s end left me holding my breath. This city thrives on power vacuums, and watching Bunny maneuver through threats while keeping an eye on Kingstown’s chaos reminded me that in this town, trust is as rare as a quiet night.

Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1 Ending Explained: What Now for Ellen, Julia, and Henry?

The closing scenes kept me glued to my screen. Kyle gets attacked in Ad Seg, likely orchestrated by Callahan, proving that old grudges die hard. Nina’s decisions and her choice to withhold information from Mike add layers to the intrigue. The episode left me wondering: is she genuinely cautious, or is there something darker at play?

Mike’s reaction is going to be pivotal. The seeds for a tense face-off are planted, and it’s clear the next episodes will see Mike taking decisive, potentially ruthless actions to protect his brother and reclaim control.

Is Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1 Worth a Watch?

Well, co-created by Taylor Sheridan and Hugh Dillon, Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1 is a must-watch. The storytelling is tight, the tension is unrelenting, and Kyle’s arc alone makes it worth the watch. If you love thrillers that make you think while keeping you on the edge of your seat, this episode is right up your alley.

Overall, I loved it; the pacing, performances, and writing make it feel fresh while staying true to the show’s gritty DNA. Every character feels alive, every threat feels real, and every twist leaves me questioning who will survive the next few episodes. Are you ready to see how Mike handles Moses and keeps his family intact? Because I can’t wait! Drop your thoughts about the episode in the comments below; let’s hash it out!

Mayor of Kingstown Season 4 Episode 1 is streaming now on Paramount+. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *