From Hollywood thrillers to chilling docudramas, real-life serial killers like Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, and Ed Gein have inspired countless adaptations. These stories fascinate audiences because they blend true crime with psychological horror, blurring the line between reality and fiction.
While some of these films and shows strive for accuracy and empathy for victims, others lean into exploitation, raising ethical questions about sensationalizing tragedy. Other times, they take ‘creative liberties’ for views and entertainment.
Hence, in this ranking, we will break down some of the most notable films and television adaptations of real-life serial killers. From the forgettable and exploitative to the haunting and well-crafted, we will rank them all here. Whether you are a true-crime buff or a horror fan, here’s how some of the most infamous killers’ screen versions stack up!
10. Ted Bundy (2002)
This low-budget crime drama starring Michael Reilly Burke as Bundy tried to cash in on true-crime interest but ended up feeling cheap and exploitative. The film leans heavily into lurid details without adding psychological insight or historical accuracy.
While it is pretty disturbing, it is widely considered one of the weaker Bundy adaptations out there. Forgettable and exploitative, it is nonetheless a film that any crime drama fan should watch.
Streaming: Available now for rent on Apple TV+.
Death Row Confidential: Secrets of a Serial Killer: Release Date, Time, & Where to Watch
9. Gacy (2003)
Starring Mark Holton as the infamous Killer Clown serial killer, John Wayne Gacy, the film is rather sluggish and poorly paced. Failing to capture the true horror of Gacy’s crime or his psychology, the film is disappointing for how it fails to properly showcase the disturbing charisma he wielded in real life.
A stark reminder that any adaptation needs to really tap into the nuances and atrocities of the subject, the film falls flat. A missed opportunity that holds little importance today.
Streaming: Available now for streaming on Netflix.
8. In the Light of the Moon/Ed Gein (2000)
Known as the inspiration for Psycho’s Norman Bates and The Texas Chainsaw Massacre’s Leatherface, Ed Gein’s story is legendary. But this adaptation is not so legendary or ‘worthy’ of the status he has assumed in popular culture.
This direct-to-video movie starring Steve Railsback sticks closer to reality than earlier fictionalized takes, but it suffers from weak production and slow pacing. Still, it does deserve a bit of credit for showing what an abusive upbringing can do to a person.
Streaming: Available now for streaming on Netflix.
7. Boston Strangler (2023)
A journalistic procedural drama starring Keira Knightley as reporter Loretta McLaughlin, it tells the story of the Boston Strangler through the eyes of journalists who uncovered the murders. The film, unfortunately, does not really do justice.
Critics point out that the film has occasionally dramatized events, yet it is a clear attempt to center on victims. A modern example of adapting a serial-crime story while emphasizing reporting and systematic failure, it is nonetheless a good watch.
Streaming: Available now on Hulu.
6. Summer of Sam (1999)
Spike Lee’s Summer of Sam isn’t a direct biography of David Berkowitz; it’s an atmospheric ensemble drama about New York City in the summer of 1977, with the Son of Sam murders as a menacing backdrop.
The film uses a serial-killings-as-social-panic angle, making it uneven but artistically ambitious. It is a persuasive example of how a killer’s terror can be shown through cultural ripple effects rather than direct portraiture.
Streaming: Available now for rent on Prime Video or Apple TV+.
Is ‘The Serial Killer’s Apprentice’ a True Story? The Real-Life Case, Explained
5. The Iceman (2012)
Based on the life of contract killer Richard Kuklinski, The Iceman trades sensationalism for the grim mundanity of a man who compartmentalized murder and family life. It is based on Anthony Bruno’s The Iceman: The True Story of a Cold-Blooded Killer.
Michael Shannon’s lead performance earned praise even when critics felt the film didn’t fully interrogate its subject’s psychology. However, it is more measured than many pulp serial-killer movies.
Streaming: Available now for streaming on Prime Video.
4. Dahmer — Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story (2022)
Ryan Murphy’s Dahmer is a raw, graphic, and intense crime drama television series. Available on Netflix, it has sparked intense debate and is a ratings juggernaut that also rekindled criticism for retraumatizing victims’ families and for how it frames Dahmer.
Evan Peters’ performance and the series’s scale made it culturally unavoidable. While defenders call it a necessary look at systemic failures (police, social patterns), critics say it profits from suffering and gore. Whether you see it as a landmark or exploitation, it forced a national conversation about representation and responsibility.
Streaming: All episodes are now available for streaming on Netflix
3. Monster (2003)
Patty Jenkins’ Monster, with Charlize Theron’s Oscar-winning performance, dramatizes Aileen Wuornos’s life and crimes. Wuornos was a street pr*stitute who murdered seven male clients and was eventually tried and executed for her crimes in 2002.
The film attempts to humanize a complex, damaged figure without excusing her murders. Theron’s transformation and the film’s gritty realism make it hard to ignore. Monster sparked debate about empathy vs. excusing violence, but it’s widely respected as a powerful actor-driven true-crime drama. Moreover, if you are a fan of Theron, this is one of her best acting jobs of all time, if not the absolute best.
Streaming: Available now for streaming on Prime Video.
2. Zodiac (2007)
David Fincher’s Zodiac isn’t a whodunit with a neat conclusion because the real case remains unresolved. It is slow and a procedural obsession piece that follows the investigators and journalists consumed by the case.
Fincher’s meticulous direction and refusal to invent a tidy finale make the film an absolute standout. It is less about the killer’s mythology and more about how a single unseen predator can warp lives and careers. Critics widely praise it as one of the best modern true-crime films, and some even hail it as Fincher’s magnum opus.
Streaming: Available now for rent on Prime Video or Apple TV+.
Steve Carell’s Serial Killer Look Shut Down His Best Movie That’s Returning to Theaters
1. Psycho (1960)
Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho is neither a documentary nor a literal biopic, but it is a fictional adaptation of Robert Bloch’s novel of the same name, which was loosely inspired by Ed Gein.
Norman Bates became the archetype for cinematic serial-killer characters, and Hitchcock’s film reframed how psychological horror could be shown on screen and inspired countless later works that drew from real-life monstrousness. Psycho is rated a classic because it turned real deviance into lasting, artful cinema rather than lurid exploitation.
Streaming: Available now for streaming on Prime Video or Apple TV+.
Now that we have reached the end of this list, let us know in the comments below which of these ten adaptations above is best in the genre? Or tell us which ones you would add or swap into the top ten!
In the meantime, for more such lists and coverage, keep following FandomWire— your one-stop destination for all things entertainment!
